Different PCB Surface Treatments: Types, Applications, and Comparisons

Printed Circuit Board (PCB) surface finishing plays a crucial role in ensuring reliable soldering, corrosion resistance, and electrical performance. Choosing the right surface finish depends on factors such as cost, shelf life, durability, and application requirements. This article explores various PCB surface treatment methods, their characteristics, advantages, and applications based on the provided comparison table.

---

1. Different PCB Surface Treatments, Hot Air Solder Leveling (HASL) / Lead-Free HASL

Overview:

HASL is one of the most widely used and cost-effective surface finishes. It involves dipping the PCB into molten tin-lead (or lead-free solder) and then using hot air knives to remove excess solder, leaving a uniform coating.

Key Features:

✔ Cost-effective and widely available
✔ Good solderability
✔ Moderate durability
✔ Suitable for most PCB applications

Applications:

• General PCB manufacturing
• Consumer electronics
• IC substrates
• BGA (Ball Grid Array) PCBs

Limitations:

• Uneven surface, which can cause assembly issues for fine-pitch components
• Not ideal for high-frequency applications
• Oxidation over time

---

2.Different PCB Surface Treatments, Immersion Gold (ENIG – Electroless Nickel Immersion Gold)

Overview:

ENIG consists of a thin layer of gold (Au) over a nickel (Ni) barrier layer. This finish provides excellent corrosion resistance and maintains solderability over time.

Key Features:

✔ Flat surface finish, ideal for fine-pitch components
✔ Excellent oxidation and corrosion resistance
✔ Good for multiple reflow cycles
✔ Long shelf life

Applications:

• High-reliability PCBs
• Industrial and medical equipment
• High-frequency applications

Limitations:

• Higher cost than HASL
• “Black pad” defect can occur if not properly processed

---

3. Different PCB Surface Treatments, Organic Solderability Preservative (OSP) / OSP + Immersion Silver

Overview:

OSP is an organic protective layer applied to copper pads to prevent oxidation while maintaining good solderability. It is an eco-friendly, lead-free alternative.

Key Features:

✔ Environmentally friendly and lead-free
✔ Low-cost process
✔ Smooth and uniform surface
✔ Ideal for reflow soldering

Applications:

• Short-lifecycle products
• Consumer electronics
• High-volume PCB production

Limitations:

• Limited durability; prone to oxidation over time
• Not suitable for multiple reflow cycles
• Sensitive to handling and storage conditions

---

4. Different PCB Surface Treatments, Immersion Silver (Ag)

Overview:

Immersion silver provides excellent conductivity and is commonly used in RF and high-frequency applications. It offers a flat surface for fine-pitch assembly.

Key Features:

✔ Good electrical performance
✔ Flat surface for fine-pitch components
✔ Lower cost than ENIG
✔ Better signal integrity for high-speed applications

Applications:

• RF and microwave PCBs
• Automotive electronics
• High-speed signal transmission circuits

Limitations:

• Prone to tarnishing if not stored properly
• Requires anti-oxidation treatment
• Not as durable as ENIG

---

5. Different PCB Surface Treatments, Immersion Tin (IMT)

Overview:

Immersion tin provides a thin, uniform tin layer over copper pads, offering a flat, solderable surface without lead or nickel.

Key Features:

✔ Flat and smooth surface
✔ Lead-free and RoHS compliant
✔ Lower cost than ENIG
✔ Good for fine-pitch assembly

Applications:

• Fine-pitch and HDI PCBs
• Consumer electronics
• Industrial applications

Limitations:

• Short shelf life
• Prone to tin whisker formation
• Oxidation risk over time

---

6. Electroplated Gold (Hard Gold – Au/Ni Plating)

Overview:

Electroplated gold involves a thicker, hard gold layer over nickel, making it highly durable and resistant to wear.

Key Features:

✔ Excellent wear resistance
✔ Ideal for high-reliability applications
✔ Strong corrosion resistance
✔ Good conductivity

Applications:

• High-reliability connectors
• IC bonding pads
• Military and aerospace applications

Limitations:

• Higher cost due to gold content
• Not ideal for soldering large areas

---

7. Electroplated Silver (SPS)

Overview:

Electroplated silver provides high conductivity and is commonly used in high-frequency applications such as telecommunications.

Key Features:

✔ Superior electrical performance
✔ Good corrosion resistance
✔ Flat and uniform surface

Applications:

• Communication devices
• High-frequency RF PCBs

Limitations:

• Can be affected by environmental factors like sulfur exposure

---

8. Electroplated Tin (TP)

Overview:

Electroplated tin is mainly used in communication equipment and offers good solderability and oxidation resistance.

Key Features:

✔ Low cost
✔ Moderate durability
✔ Decent solderability

Applications:

• Consumer electronics
• Communication devices

Limitations:

• Lower durability than gold or silver

---

9. Gold Finger (GF) Plating

Overview:

Gold finger plating is used in connector interfaces, where repeated insertions and removals require strong wear resistance.

Key Features:

✔ High durability
✔ Excellent conductivity
✔ Wear-resistant coating

Applications:

• Edge connectors
• Plug-in boards

Limitations:

• Not suitable for soldering applications

---

10. Thick Gold (ATP) Plating

Overview:

Thick gold plating is used for signal transmission and bonding applications that require high reliability.

Key Features:

✔ Superior electrical conductivity
✔ Durable and wear-resistant

Applications:

• Signal transmission boards
• Bonding applications

Limitations:

• Higher cost due to thick gold usage

---

Comparison Table of PCB Surface Finishes

Surface Finish	Cost	Solderability	Durability	Applications
HASL	Low	Good	Moderate	General PCBs
ENIG	Medium-High	Excellent	High	High-reliability PCBs
OSP	Low	Good	Low	Consumer electronics
Immersion Silver	Medium	Excellent	Moderate	RF, high-speed PCBs
Immersion Tin	Medium	Good	Moderate	Fine-pitch PCBs
Hard Gold	High	Low	Very High	Connectors, aerospace
Electroplated Silver	High	Excellent	Moderate	High-frequency PCBs
Electroplated Tin	Low	Good	Low	Communication devices
Gold Finger	High	Low	Very High	Edge connectors
Thick Gold	Very High	High	High	Signal transmission

---

Conclusion

Choosing the right PCB surface treatment depends on cost, durability, solderability, and application requirements. For general electronics, HASL and OSP are cost-effective options. For high-reliability applications, ENIG, hard gold, and immersion silver offer superior performance. Gold finger plating remains the best choice for connectors and edge contacts.

At Shenzhen Shuoqiang Electronics, we provide high-quality PCBs with various surface treatments tailored to different applications. Contact us today for custom PCB manufacturing solutions!

our linkedin sqpcb.com